Hostname: page-component-669899f699-rg895 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-05-05T01:43:01.333Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

A Korean Tragedy

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  14 March 2025

Tim Beal
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Core share and HTML view are not available for this content. However, as you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the ‘Save PDF’ action button.

Moon Jae-in's failure to challenge South Korea's servile relationship to the United States has condemned his presidency to impotence. As the ‘August Crisis’ unfolds the South Korean president has little influence over the situation. He is spurned by Pyongyang, has no traction in Beijing or Tokyo, and is taken for granted in Washington.

Keywords

Moon Jae-inUS-ROK allianceUSChinaNorth and South KoreaClientelism
Type
Research Article
Information
Asia-Pacific Journal , Volume 15 , Issue 16 , August 2017 , e3
Creative Commons
Creative Common License - CCCreative Common License - BYCreative Common License - NCCreative Common License - ND
This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-No Derivatives licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/), which permits non-commercial re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is unaltered and is properly cited. The written permission of Cambridge University Press must be obtained for commercial re-use or in order to create a derivative work.
Copyright
Copyright © The Authors 2017

References

Sources

Associated Press. “Senior US official cranks up pressure on South Korea to cut crude oil imports from Iran.” Washington Post, 17 January 2012.Google Scholar
Bandow, Doug. “Who Poses Tougher Challenge For Donald Trump: South Korea's Moon Jae-In Or The North's Kim Jong-Un?” Forbes, 17 May 2017.Google Scholar
Beal, Tim. “Hegemony and Resistance, Compellence and Deterrence: Deconstructing the North Korean ‘Threat’ and Identifying America's Strategic Alternatives.” Journal of Political Criticism, December 2017.Google Scholar
Beal, Tim. “The Korean Peninsula within the Framework of US Global Hegemony.” The Asia Pacific Journal - Japan Focus 14, no. 22:3 (13 November 2016).Google Scholar
Boot, Max. “Donald Trump Is Proving Too Stupid to Be President.” Foreign Policy, 16 June 2017.Google Scholar
Cheng, Jonathan. “National Security Chief Tells South Korea U.S. Will Pay for Defense System.” Wall Street Journal, 30 April 2017.Google Scholar
Cheng, Jonathan, and Gale, Alastair. “North Korea Missile Launch Threatens U.S. Strategy in Asia.” Wall Street Journal, 4 July 2017.Google Scholar
“Cheong Wa Dae Wants to Keep THAAD off Summit Agenda.” Chosun Ilbo, 7 June 2017.Google Scholar
Cho, Il-jun. “US asking S. Korea to increase defense cost share, while using funds for relocation.” Hankyoreh, 16 July 2017.Google Scholar
Cho, Ki-weon. “Japan reportedly to deploy Aegis Ashore system instead of THAAD.” Hankyoreh, 24 June 2017.Google Scholar
Cho, Kye-wan. “In first half of 2017, THAAD retaliation caused $4.3 billion in losses for S. Korean companies.” Hankyoreh, 6 July 2017.Google Scholar
Cho, Kye-wan. “President Trump signals intention to renegotiate KORUS FTA at summit with Pres. Moon” Hankyoreh, 1 July 2017.Google Scholar
Cho, Yi-jun. “U.S. Senate Bill Would Thwart Reopening of Kaesong Complex.” Chosun Ilbo, 24 July 2017.Google Scholar
Choe, Sang-hun. “American Peace Activist Is Denied Entry to South Korea.” New York Times, 17 July 2017.Google Scholar
Choe, Sang-hun. “South Korea Proposes Military Talks With North at Their Border.” New York Times, 17 July 2017.Google Scholar
Choi, Ha-young. “S. Korea, US reaffirm ‘close and transparent’ cooperation.” Korea Times, 11 August 2017.Google Scholar
“Defense ministry seals deal on site for THAAD.” Yonhap, 16 November 2016.Google Scholar
Doucette, Jamie, and Koo, Se-Woong. “Distorting Democracy: Politics by Public Security in Contemporary South Korea.” The Asia Pacific Journal (2 December 2013).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Draudt, Darcie. “THAAD and the Politicization of Missile Defense in South Korea” SinoNK, 29 July 2016.Google Scholar
Editorial., “China's petty backlash over THAAD deployment.” Hankyoreh, 4 August 2016.Google Scholar
Editorial., “Moon's Overtures to N.Korea Are Troubling Alliance with U.S.” Chosun Ilbo, 19 July 2017.Google Scholar
Editorial., “Moon Must Resolve THAAD Controversy on U.S. Trip.” Chosun Ilbo, 29 June 2017.Google Scholar
Editorial., “Need a lasting solution to China-US conflict over THAAD.” Hankyoreh, 16 March 2017.Google Scholar
Editorial., “No more political maneuvering by the NIS.” Hankyoreh, 5 December 2013.Google Scholar
Editorial., “Park Needs to Balance Closer Ties with China.” Chosun Ilbo, 7 September 2015.Google Scholar
Editorial., “Ramming through THAAD deployment both irresponsible and dangerous.” Hankyoreh, 8 March 2017.Google Scholar
Editorial., “Sanctions on Pyongyang.” Korea Times, 24 May 2012.Google Scholar
Editorial., “Seoul Seems Hell-Bent on Being Duped Again by N.Korea.” Chosun Ilbo, 18 July 2017.Google Scholar
Editorial., “South Korea-China summit signals hope amid challenging circumstances.” Hankyoreh, 7 July 2017.Google Scholar
Editorial., “A successful summit.” JoongAng Ilbo, 3 July 2017.Google Scholar
Elich, Gregory. “THAAD Comes to Korea, But at What Cost?” Counterpunch, 16 August 2016.Google Scholar
Elich, Gregory. “US-North Korean Relations in a Time of Change.” Counterpunch, 13 February 2017.Google Scholar
Fifield, Anna. “Are we on the brink of nuclear war with North Korea? Probably not.” Washington Post, 11 August 2017.Google Scholar
Frank, Rudiger, and Clément, Théo. “Closing the Kaesŏng Industrial Zone: An Assessment.” The Asia Pacific Journal 14, no. 6:5 (15 March 2016).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gil, Yun-hyung. “Japanese community with THAAD radar glumly says ‘it's ok’.” Hankyoreh, 18 July 2016.Google Scholar
Glaser, John. “The Case Against U.S. Overseas Military Bases.” Foreign Affairs, 25 July 2017.Google Scholar
Hong, Dae-seon. “Perfect storm of complications has Hyundai Motor facing down a crisis” Hankyoreh, 23 July 2017.Google Scholar
Jeong, Woo-sang, and Lim, Min-hyuk. “Moon Wins U.S. Support for ‘Leading Role’ in Talks with N.Korea.” Chosun Ilbo, 3 July 2017.Google Scholar
“Joint statement by the Russian and Chinese foreign ministries on the Korean Peninsula's problems.” Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Russian Federation, 4 July 2017.Google Scholar
“Joint statement of Presidents of South Korea and the United States”. Korea Times, 30 June 2017.Google Scholar
Jun, Ji-hye. “Moon halts THAAD deployment.” Korea Times, 7 June 2017.Google Scholar
Jung, In-hwan. “Pres. Moon setting his N. Korea policy with proposal for talks.” Hankyoreh, 18 July 2017.Google Scholar
Jung, In-hwan, and Kim, Ji-eun. “North Korea may prefer direct dialogue with the US to inter-Korean talks.” Hankyoreh, 22 July 2917.Google Scholar
Jung, Yu-gyung. “Seven hours ”felt like seven years“ - waiting for S. Korea-US summit joint statement.” Hankyoreh, 3 July 2017.Google Scholar
Kang, Seung-woo “Moon's US visit brings economic achievements.” Korea Times, 4 July 2017.Google Scholar
Kim, Hyo-jin. “Moon's dialogue offer to N. Korea unwelcome in US, Japan.” Korea Times, 18 July 2017.Google Scholar
Kim, Jack “South Korea imposes new wave of Iran sanctions.” Reuters, 8 September 2010.Google Scholar
Kim, Jae-kyoung. “Analysts expect ‘full-scale resetting of KORUS FTA‘” Korea Times, 19 July 2017.Google Scholar
Kim, Jeong-soo. “What the gov't won't say about the electromagnetic waves emitted by THAAD.” Hankyoreh, 2 August 2016.Google Scholar
Kim, ji-eun. “Korean-American anti-THAAD activist barred from entering South Korea.” Hankyoreh, 25 July 2017.Google Scholar
Kim, ji-eun. “North Korea still with no official response to South's dialogue offer” Hankyoreh, 21 July 2017.Google Scholar
Kim, Ji-eun, Lim, Kyu-won, and Yi, Yong-in. “Expert advice on the August crisis on the Korean Peninsula: Seoul should make its opposition to war even clearer to Washington.” Hankyoreh, 11 August 2017.Google Scholar
Kim, Ji-eun, and Yong-in, Yi. “THAAD missile defense system to become operational soon” Hankyoreh, 28 April 2017.Google Scholar
Kim, Ji-suk. “The Korean peninsula amid US-China confrontation.” Hankyoreh, 15 October 2015.Google Scholar
Kim, Jin-cheol, and Kim, Eui-gyum. “Was Choi Sun-sil behind the closing of the Kaesong Industrial Complex?” Hankyoreh, 27 October 2016.Google Scholar
Kim, Jong-hoon, and Lee, Hyun (Interviewer). “S Korean Progressives Launch New Party to Complete ‘Candlelight Revolution’.” Zoom in Korea, 4 August 2017.Google Scholar
Kim, Kyu-won. “At 2007 inter-Korean summit, then-Pres. Roh discussed autonomy” Hankyoreh, 26 June 2013.Google Scholar
Kim, Oi-hyun. “With consumer boycotts over THAAD, S. Korea-China relations in a tailspin.” Hankyoreh, 1 March 2017.Google Scholar
Kim, Rahn. “Greater Trump trade pressure looming” Korea Times, 3 July 2017.Google Scholar
Kim, Rahn. “What makes Moon different from Roh Moo-hyun” Korea Times, 8 May 2017.Google Scholar
Ko, Young Dae. “U.S. Pushing Destabilizing ‘Missile Defense’ in Asia-Pacific.” Solidarity for Peace and Reconciliation in Korea (SPARK), 27 April 2015.Google Scholar
Kwack, Jung-soo. “S. Korean companies hit by China's THAAD retaliation disappointed at lack of solution from Moon-Xi summit” Hankyoreh, 8 July 2017.Google Scholar
Kwak, Byong-chan. “The NIS's long history of political interference.” Hankyoreh, 12 July 2013.Google Scholar
Landler, Mark. “Trump Takes More Aggressive Stance With U.S. Friends and Foes in Asia.” New York Times, 30 June 2017.Google Scholar
Lee, Hyun. “North Korea's ICBM and South Korea's Confusing Response.” Korea Policy Institute, 10 July 2017.Google Scholar
Lee, Kil-seong, and Chae, Sung-jin. “Lotte Faces Massive Tax Probe in China After THAAD Decision.” Chosun Ilbo, 2 December 2016.Google Scholar
Lee, Rachel. “US, NK may take drastic turn to dialogue.” Korea Times, 11 August 2017.Google Scholar
Lee, Se-young. “Pres. Moon: THAAD agreement included deployment of only one launcher this year” Hankyoreh, 23 June 2017.Google Scholar
Lee, Se-young, and Kim, Ji-eun. “Foreign Minister says environmental assessment can build public support for THAAD.” Hankyoreh, 27 June 2017.Google Scholar
Lee, Yong-soo. “Korea, U.S. Skirt THAAD Controversy During Summit.” Chosun Ilbo, 3 July 2017.Google Scholar
Lee, Yong-soo, and Kim, Myong-song. “N.Korea Ignores Proposal of Military Talks.” Chosun Ilbo, 21 July 2017.Google Scholar
“Lift the May 24 measures and get down to business with the North.” Hankyoreh, 24 May 2012.Google Scholar
Lim, Ji-sun, Im, In-tack, Cho, Il-jun, and Choi, Hyun-june. “South Korean gov't on the hook for $870 million to clean up US base contamination.” Hankyoreh, 12 July 2017.Google Scholar
“Local residents don't want US military base to be built in Kyoto.” Japan Press Weekly, 5 October 2014.Google Scholar
“Moon-Trump Summit: Two Issues to Watch for.” Zoom in Korea, 27 June 2017.Google Scholar
“Moon Says THAAD Deal Was ‘Mysteriously’ Rushed.” Chosun Ilbo, 23 June 2017.Google Scholar
Mullany, Gerry, and Gordon, Michael R. “U.S. Starts Deploying Thaad Antimissile System in South Korea, After North's Tests.” New York Times, 6 March 2017.Google Scholar
Nakamura, David, and Johnson, Jenna. “With South Korean president, Trump denounces ‘reckless and brutal’ regime in North Korea.” Washington Post, 30 June 2017.Google Scholar
“NIS Denies Abducting N.Korean Waitresses.” Chosun Ilbo, 28 April 2016.Google Scholar
Oh, Young-jin. “Are we America lovers or China lovers?” Korea Times, 21 July 2017.Google Scholar
Oh, Young-jin. “Pyeongtaek Garrison vulnerable to chemical, biological missile attacks.” Korea Times, 21 July 2017.Google Scholar
Ortiz, Erik, and Yamamoto, Arata. “Sen. Lindsey Graham: Trump Says War With North Korea an Option.” NBC, 2 August 2017.Google Scholar
Park, Byong-su. “Korea to significantly cut oil imports from Iran.” Hankyoreh, 17 January 2012.Google Scholar
Park, Byong-su. “Pres. Moon starting diplomatic moves to address THAAD issue with China” Hankyoreh, 12 May 2017.Google Scholar
Park, Byong-su. “US partners should cut Iranian crude imports, Einhorn says.” Hankyoreh, 18 January 2012.Google Scholar
Park, Byong-su, and Kim, Ji-eun. “North Korea could look to add items to military talks agenda.” Hankyoreh, 18 July 2017.Google Scholar
Park, Byong-su, and Kim, Ji-eun. “THAAD deployment could slow down as Pres. Moon orders environmental assessment.” Hankyoreh, 6 June 2017.Google Scholar
Park, Byong-su, and Lee, Se-young. “Moon admin.'s governance plan signals step back on pushing for OPCON transfer.” Hankyoreh, 20 July 2017.Google Scholar
Park, Si-soo. “Korea to join sanctions against Iran.” Korea Times, 11 December 2011.Google Scholar
Postol, Theodore, Zhao, Tong, and Dalton, Toby. “Is U.S. Missile Defense Aimed at China?” Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, 15 October 2015.Google Scholar
Reuters, . “Trump Calls for Firm Response to North Korea, Targets Seoul on Trade.” New York Times, 1 July 2017.Google Scholar
Ripley, Will. “Tearful North Korean waitresses: Our ‘defector’ colleagues were tricked.” CNN, 21 April 2016.Google Scholar
Rucker, Philip “Trump: ‘We may terminate’ U.S.-South Korea trade agreement.” Washington Post, 28 April 2017.Google Scholar
Sanger, David E, and Harris, Gardiner. “U.S. Pressed to Pursue Deal to Freeze North Korea Missile Tests.” New York Times, 21 June 2017.Google Scholar
Sim, Hyun-jung, and Shon, Jin-seok. “THAAD Retaliation from China Unlikely to Kill Business.” Chosun Ilbo, 6 March 2017.Google Scholar
Snyder, Scott. “Launch of the Trump-Moon Era in U.S.-Korea Relations.” Council of Foreign Relations, 12 July 2017.Google Scholar
“South Korean leader looks for common ground with Trump.” KALB, 29 June 2017.Google Scholar
Stromberg, Stephen. “Trump is dangerously incompetent.” Washington Post, 15 May 2017.Google Scholar
Suh, JJ. “Missile Defense and the Security Dilemma: THAAD, Japan's ”Proactive Peace,“ and the Arms Race in Northeast Asia.” The Asia Pacific Journal - Japan Focus, 27 April 2017.Google Scholar
“TPY-2 X-band Radar.” Center for Inetrantional and Strategic Studies, 25 April 2016.Google Scholar
“U.S. Troops in S. Korea Can Never Escape Strikes by KPA's Long-range Artillery: Panmunjom Mission.” KCNA, 14 July 2017.Google Scholar
Walt, Stephen. “The Global Consequences of Trump's Incompetence.” Foreign Policy, 18 July 2017.Google Scholar
“Why China is wrong to be furious about THAAD.” Economist, 23 March 2017.Google Scholar
Yi, Whan-woo. “China's THAAD retaliation may backfire” Korea Times, 12 April 2017.Google Scholar
Yi, Yong-in. “Moon says Trump's trade comments were ”outside of what was agreed upon“.” Hankyoreh, 3 July 2017.Google Scholar
Yi, Yong-in, and Choi, Hye-jung. “McMaster's doublespeak on THAAD costs feeding fire started by Trump.” Hankyoreh, 1 May 2017.Google Scholar
Yi, Yong-in, and Kim, Ji-eun. “Trump sends South Korea a $1 billion invoice for THAAD” Hankyoreh, 29 April 2017.Google Scholar
Yonhap, . “THAAD deployment unrelated to political situation in South Korea: State Department.” Korea Times, 14 March 2017.Google Scholar
Yonhap, . “Top court rejects lawyers' protection request for N. Korea defectors.” Korea Times, 8 March 2017.Google Scholar
Yonhap, . “White House: Current conditions ‘far away’ to reopen inter-Korean talks.” Korea Times, 18 July 2017.Google Scholar