Do People Know the Law? Empirical Evidence about Legal Knowledge and Its Implications for Compliance

doi:10.1017/9781108759458.032

32 - Do People Know the Law? Empirical Evidence about Legal Knowledge and Its Implications for Compliance

from Part V - Capacity and Opportunity

Published online by Cambridge University Press: 07 May 2021

Benjamin van Rooij

Edited by

Benjamin van Rooij and

D. Daniel Sokol

Show author details

Benjamin van Rooij: Affiliation:
School of Law, University of Amsterdam
D. Daniel Sokol: Affiliation:
University of Florida

Book contents

Get access

Summary

Abstract: Legal knowledge is a core aspect in compliance. For law to shape behaviour, people whose conduct the law tries to influence should know the law. This chapter reviews the body of existing empirical research about legal knowledge. It assesses the extent to which laypersons and professionals know and understand legal rules across various domains including employment, family affairs, criminal justice, education and health care. This body of work shows that ignorance and misunderstanding of the law are common across these domains. There is variation and for some laws, amongst some people and in some jurisdictions, there is more or less legal knowledge. Also, the review shows that there is evidence that people tend to equate their own norms with the rules of the law. The chapter concludes by discussing what these findings mean for compliance and the way our laws try to steer human and organisational conduct. Here it questions compliance approaches that view it as a linear process from rule to behaviour.

Type: Chapter
Information: The Cambridge Handbook of Compliance , pp. 467 - 488

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108759458.032 [Opens in a new window]

Publisher: Cambridge University Press

Print publication year: 2021

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Book purchase

Temporarily unavailable

References

Abbott, Kenneth W., Levi-Faur, David and Snidal, Duncan. 2017. ‘Theorizing Regulatory Intermediaries: The RIT Model’. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 670 no. 1: 14–35.Google Scholar

Abegglen, W. P. (1986). ‘Knowledge of United States Supreme Court Decisions Affecting Education Held by Selected Tennessee Public School Personnel (Law)’. PhD Thesis, East Tennessee State University. https://dc.etsu.edu/etd/2621.Google Scholar

Albrecht, Stan L., and Green, Miles. 1977. ‘Cognitive Barriers to Equal Justice before the Law’. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 14 no. 2: 206–21.Google Scholar

Apel, Robert. 2013. ‘Sanctions, Perceptions, and Crime: Implications for Criminal Deterrence’. Journal of Quantitative Criminology 29 no. 1: 67–101.Google Scholar

Bench-Capon, Trevor J. M. 2015. Knowledge-Based Systems and Legal Applications, Vol. 36. Brighton, UK: Academic Press.Google Scholar

Bench-Capon, Trevor J. M., and Coenen, Frans P.. 1992. ‘Isomorphism and Legal Knowledge-Based Systems’. Artificial Intelligence and Law 1 no. 1:65–86.CrossRef Google Scholar

Bowal, Peter. 1998. ‘A Study of Lay Knowledge of Law in Canada’. Indiana International & Comparative Law Review 9: 121.Google Scholar

Cavanagh, Caitlin, and Cauffman, Elizabeth. 2017. ‘What They Don’t Know Can Hurt Them: Mothers’ Legal Knowledge and Youth Re-offending’. Psychology, Public Policy, and Law 23 no. 2: 141.Google Scholar

CCH Tax Law Editors. 2016. Internal Revenue Code: Income, Estate, Gift, Employment and Excise Taxes. New York: Wolters Kluwer CCH.Google Scholar

Chate, R. A. C. 2008. ‘An Audit of the Level of Knowledge and Understanding of Informed Consent amongst Consultant Orthodontists in England, Wales and Northern Ireland’. British Dental Journal 205 no. 12: 665.Google Scholar

Clark, T. R. 1990. ‘Mississippi Superintendents’ and Secondary Educators’ Knowledge of School Law as It Relates to Student Rights in Selected Areas’. PhD Thesis, University of Southern Mississippi. https://aquila.usm.edu/theses_dissertations/2745/.Google Scholar

Coffee, John C. Jr 1991. ‘Does Unlawful Mean Criminal?: Reflections on the Disappearing Tort/Crime Distinction in American Law’. Boston University Law Review 71: 193.Google Scholar

Cortese, Charles. 1966. ‘A Study in Knowledge and Attitudes toward the Law: The Legal Knowledge Inventory’. Rocky Mountain Social Science Journal 3: 192–204.Google Scholar

Darley, John M., Carlsmith, Kevin M. and Robinson, Paul H.. 2001. ‘The Ex Ante Function of the Criminal Law’. Law and Society Review:165–90.Google Scholar

Darley, John M., Sanderson, Catherine A. and LaMantia, Peter S.. 1996. ‘Community Standards for Defining Attempt Inconsistencies with the Model Penal Code’. American Behavioral Scientist 39 no. 4: 405–20.Google Scholar

Denvir, Catrina, Balmer, Nigel J. and Buck, Alexy. 2012. ‘Informed Citizens? Knowledge of Rights and the Resolution of Civil Justice Problems’. Journal of Social Policy 41 no. 3: 591–614.Google Scholar

Denvir, Catrina, Balmer, Nigel J. and Pleasence, Pascoe. 2013. ‘When Legal Rights Are Not a Reality: Do Individuals Know Their Rights and How Can We Tell?’. Journal of Social Welfare and Family Law 35 no.1: 139–60.Google Scholar

Eberwein III, Howard Jacob. 2008. Raising Legal Literacy in Public Schools: A Call for Principal Leadership: A National Study of Secondary School Principals’ Knowledge of Public School Law. University of Massachusetts Amherst.Google Scholar

Edelman, Lauren B., and Talesh, Shauhin A.. 2011. ‘To Comply or Not to Comply – That Isn’t the Question: How Organizations Construct the Meaning of Compliance’. Explaining Compliance: Business Responses to Regulation:103–22.Google Scholar

Edwards, Deborah L., and Mahling, Dirk E.. 1997. ‘Toward Knowledge Management Systems in the Legal Domain’. Proceedings of the International ACM SIGGROUP Conference on Supporting Group Work: The Integration Challenge.Google Scholar

Estlund, Cynthia L. 2002. ‘How Wrong Are Employees about Their Rights, and Why Does It Matter?’ New York University Law Review 77: 6.Google Scholar

Gallagher, Mary E. 2006. ‘Mobilizing the Law in China: “Informed Disenchantment” and the Development of Legal Consciousness’. Law & Society Review 40 no. 4: 783–816.Google Scholar

Ginther, Matthew R., Shen, Francis X., Bonnie, Richard J. and Hoffman, Morris B.. 2014. ‘The Language of Men’s Rea’. Vanderbilt Law Review 67: 1327.Google Scholar

Ginther, Matthew R., Shen, Francis X., Bonnie, Richard J., Hoffman, Morris B., Jones, Owen D. and Simons, Kenneth W.. 2018. ‘Decoding Guilty Minds: How Jurors Attribute Knowledge and Guilt’. Vanderbilt Law Review 71: 241.Google Scholar

Givelber, Daniel J., Bowers, William J. and Blitch, Carolyn L.. 1984. ‘Tarasoff, Myth and Reality: An Empirical Study of Private Law in Action’. Wisconsin Law Review: 443.Google Scholar

Goodwin-De Faria, Christine, and Marinos, Voula. 2012. ‘Youth Understanding & Assertion of Legal Rights: Examining the Roles of Age and Power’. International Journal of Children’s Rights 20 no. 3: 343–64.Google Scholar

Gray, G., and Pelisse, J.. 2019. ‘Frontline Workers and the Role of Legal and Regulatory Intermediaries’. Sciences Po LIEPP Working Paper, n°94, 2019–10–12.Google Scholar

Grisso, Thomas, Steinberg, Laurence, Woolard, Jennifer, Cauffman, Elizabeth, Scott, Elizabeth, Graham, Sandra, Lexcen, Fran, Dickon Reppucci, N. and Schwartz, Robert. 2003. ‘Juveniles’ Competence to Stand Trial: A Comparison of Adolescents’ and Adults’ Capacities as Trial Defendants’. Law and Human Behavior 27 no. 4: 333–63.Google Scholar

Kennedy, Duncan. 1982. ‘Legal Education and the Reproduction of Hierarchy’. Journal of Legal Education 32: 591.Google Scholar

Kim, Pauline T. 1998. ‘An Empirical Challenge to Employment at Will’. New Zealand Journal of Employment Relations 23 no. 2: 91.Google Scholar

Kim, Pauline T. 1999. ‘Norms, Learning and Law: Exploring the Influences of Workers’ Legal Knowledge’. University of Illinois Legal Review 1999 no. 2: 447–516.Google Scholar

Leary, Thomas B. 1990. ‘The Commission’s New Option That Favors Judicial Discretion in Corporate Sentencing’. Federal Sentencing Reporter 3: 142.Google Scholar

Littleton, Mark. 2008. ‘Teachers’ Knowledge of Education Law’. Action in Teacher Education 30 no. 2: 71–8.Google Scholar

Matsuda, Mari. 1988. ‘Affirmative Action and Legal Knowledge: Planting Seeds in Plowed-Up Ground’. Harvard Women’s Law Journal 11: 1.Google Scholar

Militello, M., Schimmel, D. and Eberwein, H. J.. 2009. ‘If They Knew, They Would Change: How Legal Knowledge Impacts Principals’ Practice’. NASSP Bulletin 93 no. 1: 27–52.Google Scholar

Moore, S. J. 1997. ‘An Assessment of Selected Knowledge of School Law from Public Educators in the State of Tennessee’. PhD Thesis, Tennessee State University. https://digitalscholarship.tnstate.edu/dissertations/AAI9806345/.Google Scholar

Pleasence, Pascoe, and Balmer, Nigel J.. 2012. ‘Ignorance in Bliss: Modeling Knowledge of Rights in Marriage and Cohabitation’. Law & Society Review 46 no. 2: 297–333.Google Scholar

Pleasence, Pascoe, Balmer, Nigel J. and Denvir, Catrina. 2017. ‘Wrong about Rights: Public Knowledge of Key Areas of Consumer, Housing and Employment Law in England and Wales’. Modern Law Review 80 no. 5: 836–59.Google Scholar

Reifman, Alan, Gusick, Spencer M. and Ellsworth, Phoebe C.. 1992. ‘Real Jurors’ Understanding of the Law in Real Cases’. Law and Human Behavior 16 no. 5: 539–54.Google Scholar

Riles, Annelise. 2006. ‘Anthropology, Human Rights, and Legal Knowledge: Culture in the Iron Cage’. American Anthropologist 108 no. 1: 52–65.Google Scholar

Rudy, Jesse. 2002. ‘What They Don’t Know Won’t Hurt Them: Defending Employment-at-Will in Light of Findings That Employees Believe They Possess Just Cause Protection’. Berkeley Journal of Employment & Labor Law 23: 307.Google Scholar

Saltstone, Scot P., Saltstone, Robert and Rowe, Brian H.. 1997. ‘Knowledge of Medical-Legal Issues: Survey of Ontario Family Medicine Residents’. Canadian Family Physician 43: 669.Google Scholar

Sametz, L., McLoughlin, C. and Streib, V.. 1981. ‘Teacher’s Survey of Knowledge of School Law and Child Abuse’. Kent, OH. ED218243.Google Scholar

Sarat, Austin. 1975. ‘Support for the Legal System: An Analysis of Knowledge, Attitudes, and Behavior’. American Politics Quarterly 3 no. 1: 3–24.Google Scholar

Sarat, Austin. 1976/7. ‘Studying American Legal Culture: An Assessment of Survey Evidence’. Law & Society Review 11: 427.CrossRef Google Scholar

Sarat, Austin, and Felstiner, William L. F.. 1989. ‘Lawyers and Legal Consciousness: Law Talk in the Divorce Lawyer’s Office’. Yale Law Journal: 1663–88.Google Scholar

Saunders, LaVell E. 1975. ‘Collective Ignorance: Public Knowledge of Family Law’. Family Coordinator:69–74.Google Scholar

Saunders, LaVell E. 1981. ‘Ignorance of the Law among Teenagers: Is It a Barrier to the Exertion of Their Rights as Citizens?’ Adolescence 16 no. 63: 711.Google Scholar

Schimmel, David, and Militello, Matthew. 2007. ‘Legal Literacy for Teachers: A Neglected Responsibility’. Harvard Educational Review 77 no. 3: 257–84.Google Scholar

Shaw, F. W. I. 1984. ‘Principals’ Knowledge of the Law of Public Education and Its Relation to Job Satisfaction’. Dissertation, University of Utah.Google Scholar

Shen, Francis X., Hoffman, Morris B., Jones, Owen D. and Greene, Joshua D.. 2011. ‘Sorting Guilty Minds’. New York University Law Review 86: 1306.Google Scholar

Shuman, Daniel W., and Weiner, Myron S.. 1981. ‘Privilege Study: An Empirical Examination of the Psychotherapist–Patient Privilege’. North Carolina Law Review 60: 893.Google Scholar

Talesh, Shauhin A. 2009. ‘The Privatization of Public Legal Rights: How Manufacturers Construct the Meaning of Consumer Law’. Law & Society Review 43 no. 3: 527–62.Google Scholar

Talesh, Shauhin A. 2015. ‘Rule‐Intermediaries in Action: How State and Business Stakeholders Influence the Meaning of Consumer Rights in Regulatory Governance Arrangements’. Law & Policy 37 nos. 1–2: 1–31.Google Scholar

Talesh, Shauhin, and Pélisse, Jérôme. 2019. ‘How Legal Intermediaries Facilitate or Inhibit Social Change’. Studies in Law, Politics, and Society 79: 111–45.Google Scholar

Thornton, Dorothy, Gunningham, Neil and Kagan, Robert A.. 2005. ‘General Deterrence and Corporate Environmental Behavior’. Law & Policy 27 no. 2: 262–88.Google Scholar

Van McCrary, S., and Swanson, Jeffrey W.. 1999. ‘Physicians’ Legal Defensiveness and Knowledge of Medical Law: Comparing Denmark and the USA’. Scandinavian Journal of Public Health 27 no. 1: 18–21.Google Scholar

Van McCrary, S., Swanson, Jeffrey W., Perkins, Henry S. and Winslade, William J.. 1992. ‘Treatment Decisions for Terminally Ill Patients: Physicians’ Legal Defensiveness and Knowledge of Medical Law’. Law, Medicine and Health Care 20 no. 4: 364–76.Google Scholar

White, Ben, Willmott, Lindy, Cartwright, Colleen, Parker, Malcolm H. and Williams, Gail. 2014. ‘Doctors’ Knowledge of the Law on Withholding and Withdrawing Life‐Sustaining Medical Treatment’. Medical Journal of Australia 201 no. 4: 229–32.Google Scholar

White, Ben, Willmott, Lindy, Parker, Malcolm, Cartwright, Colleen and Williams, Gail. 2012. ‘What Do Emergency Physicians Think of Law?’ Emergency Medicine Australasia 24 no. 4: 355–6.Google Scholar

Williams, Martha, and Hall, Jay. 1972. ‘Knowledge of the Law in Texas: Socioeconomic and Ethnic Differences’. Law & Society Review 7 no. 1: 99–118.Google Scholar

Winter, S., and May, P. J.. 2001. ‘Motivation for Compliance with Environmental Regulations’. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management 20 no. 4: 675–98.Google Scholar

Zirkel, Perry A. 1996. ‘The Law or the Lore?’ Phi Delta Kappan 77 no. 8: 579.Google Scholar