Hostname: page-component-55f67697df-q9hcs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-05-09T09:22:43.409Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Towards personalising treatment: a systematic review and meta-analysis of face-to-face efficacy moderators of cognitive-behavioral therapy and interpersonal psychotherapy for major depressive disorder

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 October 2019

Aoife Whiston ,
Claudi L. H. Bockting  and
Maria Semkovska Open the ORCID record for Maria Semkovska [Opens in a new window]
Aoife Whiston
Affiliation:
Department of Psychology, University of Limerick, Limerick, Ireland
Claudi L. H. Bockting
Affiliation:
Department of Psychiatry, Academic Medical Centre, University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, Netherlands
Maria Semkovska*
Affiliation:
Department of Psychology, University of Limerick, Limerick, Ireland Health Research Institute, University of Limerick, Limerick, Ireland
*
Author for correspondence: Maria Semkovska, E-mail: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Background

Consistent evidence suggests that face-to-face cognitive-behavioural therapy (CBT) and interpersonal psychotherapy (IPT) may be equally effective depression treatments. Current clinical research focuses on detecting the best predictors-moderators of efficacy to guide treatment personalisation. However, individual moderator studies show inconsistent findings. This systematic review and meta-analysis aimed to compare the efficacy of CBT and IPT, including combined treatment with antidepressants for depression, and evaluate the predictive power of demographic, clinical presentation and treatment characteristics moderators for both therapies.

Methods

PsycArticles, PsycINFO, PubMed and Cochrane Library were systematically searched through December 2017 for studies that have assessed individuals with major depression receiving either CBT or IPT in a face-to-face format both at pre- and post-treatment. Random-effects moderator meta-analyses were conducted.

Results

In total 168 samples from 137 studies including 11 374 participants qualified for the meta-analytic review. CBT and IPT were equally effective across all but one prespecified moderators. For psychotherapy delivered without concomitant antidepressant treatment [antidepressant medications (ADMs)], CBT was superior to IPT (g = 1.68, Qbetweenp = 0.037). Within-CBT moderator analyses showed that increased CBT efficacy was associated with lower age, high initial depression severity, individual format of administration and no adjunctive ADMs. Within-IPT analyses showed comparable efficacy across all moderators.

Conclusions

Clinical guidance around combined treatment (psychotherapy plus ADMs) should be reconsidered. CBT alone is superior to IPT alone and to combined treatment, while IPT alone is non-inferior to combined treatment. More research is needed to assess the moderating effect of older age and number of previous episodes on IPT efficacy.

Keywords

Cognitive behavioural therapyefficacy moderatorface-to-face therapyinterpersonal psychotherapymajor depressionmeta-analysissystematic review
Type
Review Article
Information
Psychological Medicine , Volume 49 , Issue 16 , December 2019 , pp. 2657 - 2668
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2019 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Article purchase

Temporarily unavailable

References

APA (2000) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. 4th Edn. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association.Google Scholar
Barth, J, Munder, T, Gerger, H, Nuesch, E, Trelle, S, Znoj, H, Juni, P and Cuijpers, P (2013) Comparative efficacy of seven psychotherapeutic interventions for patients with depression: a network meta-analysis. PLoS Medicine 10, e1001454. http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmed.1001454.Google Scholar
Bayliss, P and Holttum, S (2015) Experiences of antidepressant medication and cognitive-behavioural therapy for depression: a grounded theory study. Psychology Psychotherapy 88, 317–334. http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/papt.12040.Google Scholar
Bockting, CLH, Klein, NS, Elgersma, HJ, van Rijsbergen, GD, Slofstra, C, Ormel, J, Buskens, E, Dekker, J, de Jong, PJ, Nolen, WA, Schene, AH, Hollon, SD and Burger, H (2018) Effectiveness of preventive cognitive therapy while tapering antidepressants v. maintenance antidepressant treatment v. their combination in prevention of depressive relapse or recurrence (DRD study): a three-group, multicentre, randomised controlled trial. The Lancet Psychiatry 5, 401–410. http://dx.doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1016/S2215-0366(18)30100-7.Google Scholar
Bender, R, Bunce, C, Clarke, M, Gates, S, Lange, S, Pace, NL and Thorlund, K (2008) Attention should be given to multiplicity issues in systematic reviews. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 61, 857–865.Google Scholar
Borenstein, M, Hedges, L, Higgins, J and Rothstein, H (2009) Introduction to Meta-Analysis. West Sussex, England: Wiley.Google Scholar
Budd, R and Hughes, I (2009) The Dodo Bird Verdict – controversial, inevitable and important: a commentary on 30 years of meta-analyses. Clinical Psychology and Psychotherapy 16, 510–522. http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/cpp.648.Google Scholar
Burcusa, SL and Iacono, WG (2007) Risk for recurrence in depression. Clinical Psychology Review 27, 959–985. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cpr.2007.02.005.Google Scholar
Butler, AC, Chapman, JE, Forman, EM and Beck, AT (2006) The empirical status of cognitive-behavioral therapy: a review of meta-analyses. Clinical Psychology Review 26, 17–31. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cpr.2005.07.003.Google Scholar
Carter, JD, Luty, SE, McKenzie, JM, Mulder, RT, Frampton, CM and Joyce, PR (2011) Patient predictors of response to cognitive behaviour therapy and interpersonal psychotherapy in a randomised clinical trial for depression. Journal of Affective Disorders 128, 252–261. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jad.2010.07.002.Google Scholar
Churchill, R, Khaira, M, Gretton, V, Chilvers, C, Dewey, M, Duggan, C, Lee, A and Nottingham, C and Antidepressants in Primary Care Study, G. (2000) Treating depression in general practice: factors affecting patients' treatment preferences. The British Journal of General Practice: the Journal of the Royal College of General Practitioners 50, 905–906.Google Scholar
Cohen, JD (1988) Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioural Sciences. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.Google Scholar
Craighead, WE and Dunlop, BW (2014) Combination psychotherapy and antidepressant medication treatment for depression: for whom, when, and how. Annual Review Psychology 65, 267–300. http://dx.doi.org/10.1146/annurev.psych.121208.131653.Google Scholar
Craigie, MA and Nathan, P (2009) A nonrandomized effectiveness comparison of broad-spectrum group CBT to individual CBT for depressed outpatients in a community mental health setting. Behavior Therapy 40, 302–314. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.beth.2008.08.002.Google Scholar
Cuijpers, P, van Straten, A and Smit, F (2006) Psychological treatment of late-life depression: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. International Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry 21, 1139–1149. http://dx.doi.org/doi:10.1002/gps.1620.Google Scholar
Cuijpers, P, van Straten, A, Warmerdam, L (2008) Are individual and group treatments equally effective in the treatment of depression in adults?: A meta-analysis. The European Journal of Psychiatry 22(1), 38–51.Google Scholar
Cuijpers, P, van Straten, A, Warmerdam, L and Andersson, G (2009) Psychotherapy v. the combination of psychotherapy and pharmacotherapy in the treatment of depression: a meta-analysis. Depression and Anxiety 26, 279–288. http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/da.20519.Google Scholar
Cuijpers, P, Andersson, G, Donker, T and van Straten, A (2011) Psychological treatment of depression: results of a series of meta-analyses. Nordic Journal of Psychiatry 65, 354–364. http://dx.doi.org/10.3109/08039488.2011.596570.Google Scholar
Cuijpers, P, Ebert, DD, Acarturk, C, Andersson, G and Cristea, IA (2016) Personalized psychotherapy for adult depression: a meta-analytic review. Behaviour Therapy 47, 966–980. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.beth.2016.04.007.Google Scholar
Cyranowski, JM, Frank, E, Shear, MK, Swartz, H, Fagiolini, A, Scott, J and Kupfer, DJ (2005) Interpersonal psychotherapy for depression with panic spectrum symptoms: a Pilot Study. Depression and Anxiety 21, 140–142. http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/da.20069.Google Scholar
DerSimonian, R and Laird, N (1986) Meta-analysis in clinical trials. Controlled Clinical Trials 7, 177–188.Google Scholar
Driessen, E, Smits, N, Dekker, JJ, Peen, J, Don, FJ, Kool, S, Westra, D, Hendriksen, M, Cuijpers, P and Van, HL (2016) Differential efficacy of cognitive behavioral therapy and psychodynamic therapy for major depression: a study of prescriptive factors. Psychological Medicine 46(4), 731–744. http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/s0033291715001853.Google Scholar
Elkin, I, Gibbons, RD, Shea, MT, Sotsky, SM, Watkins, JT, Pilkonis, PA and Hedeker, D (1995) Initial severity and differential treatment outcome in the National Institute of Mental Health Treatment of Depression Collaborative Research Program. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 63, 841–847.Google Scholar
Fava, GA (2003) Can long-term treatment with antidepressant drugs worsen the course of depression? Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 64, 123–133.Google Scholar
Fava, GA, Benasi, G, Lucente, M, Offidani, E, Cosci, F and Guidi, J (2018) Withdrawal symptoms after serotonin-noradrenaline reuptake inhibitor discontinuation: systematic review. Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics 87, 195–203. http://dx.doi.org/10.1159/000491524.Google Scholar
Fournier, JC, DeRubeis, RJ, Shelton, RC, Hollon, SD, Amsterdam, JD and Gallop, R (2009) Prediction of response to medication and cognitive therapy in the treatment of moderate to severe depression. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 77, 775–787. http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/a0015401.Google Scholar
Frank, E, Cassano, GB, Rucci, P, Thompson, WK, Kraemer, HC, Fagiolini, A, Maggi, L, Kupfer, DJ, Shear, MK, Houck, PR, Calugi, S, Grochocinski, VJ, Scocco, P, Buttenfield, J and Forgione, RN (2011) Predictors and moderators of time to remission of major depression with interpersonal psychotherapy and SSRI pharmacotherapy. Psychological Medicine 41, 151–162. http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0033291710000553.Google Scholar
Gartlehner, G and Moore, CG (2008) Direct v. indirect comparisons: a summary of the evidence. International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care 24, 170–177. http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0266462308080240.Google Scholar
Harrison, F (2011) Getting started with meta-analysis. Methods in Ecology and Evolution 2, 1–10. http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.2041-210X.2010.00056.x.Google Scholar
Higgins, JP, Deeks, JJ, Altman, DG (2008) Special topics in statistics. In Higgins, JPT and Green, S (eds), Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions. Chichester (UK): John Wiley & Sons, pp. 481–529.Google Scholar
Hofmann, SG, Asnaani, A, Vonk, IJ, Sawyer, AT and Fang, A (2012) The efficacy of cognitive behavioral therapy: a review of meta-analyses. Cognitive Therapy Research 36, 427–440. http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10608-012-9476-1.Google Scholar
Hollon, SD, DeRubeis, RJ, Shelton, RC, Amsterdam, JD, Salomon, RM, O'Reardon, JP, Lovett, ML, Young, PR, Haman, KL, Freeman, BB and Gallop, R (2005 a) Prevention of relapse following cognitive therapy v. medications in moderate to severe depression. Archives of General Psychiatry 62, 417–422. http://dx.doi.org/10.1001/archpsyc.62.4.417.Google Scholar
Hollon, SD, Jarrett, RB, Nierenberg, AA, Thase, ME, Trivedi, M and Rush, AJ (2005 b) Psychotherapy and medication in the treatment of adult and geriatric depression: which monotherapy or combined treatment? Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 66, 455–468.Google Scholar
Holm, S (1979) A simple sequentially rejective multiple test procedure. Scandinavian Journal of Statistics 6(2), 65–70.Google Scholar
Honyashiki, M, Furukawa, TA, Noma, H, Tanaka, S, Chen, P, Ichikawa, K, Ono, M, Churchill, R, Hunot, V and Caldwell, DM (2014) Specificity of CBT for depression: a contribution from multiple treatments meta-analyses. Cognit Therapy Research 38, 249–260. http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10608-014-9599-7.Google Scholar
Hyer, L, Kramer, D and Sohnle, S (2004) CBT with older people: alterations and the value of the therapeutic alliance. Psychotherapy: Theory, Research, Practice, Training 41, 276–291. http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/0033-3204.41.3.276.Google Scholar
Johnstone, L (2003) Back to basics. The Psychologist 16(4), 186–187.Google Scholar
Kessler, RC, Nelson, CB, McGonagle, KA, Liu, J, Swartz, M and Blazer, DG (1996) Comorbidity of DSM-III-R major depressive disorder in the general population: results from the US National Comorbidity Survey. British Journal of Psychiatry 168(S30), 17–30.Google Scholar
Law, R (2011) Interpersonal psychotherapy for depression. Advances in Psychiatric Treatment 17, 23–31. http://dx.doi.org/10.1192/apt.bp.109.007641.Google Scholar
Lemmens, LH, Arntz, A, Peeters, FP, Hollon, SD, Roefs, A and Huibers, MJ (2011) Effectiveness, relapse prevention and mechanisms of change of cognitive therapy v. Interpersonal therapy for depression: study protocol for a randomised controlled trial. Trials 12, 150. http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/1745-6215-12-150.Google Scholar
Luty, SE, Carter, JD, McKenzie, JM, Rae, AM, Frampton, CM, Mulder, RT and Joyce, PR (2007) Randomised controlled trial of interpersonal psychotherapy and cognitive-behavioural therapy for depression. British Journal of Psychiatry 190, 496–502. http://dx.doi.org/10.1192/bjp.bp.106.024729.Google Scholar
McBride, C, Atkinson, L, Quilty, LC and Bagby, RM (2006) Attachment as moderator of treatment outcome in major depression: a randomized control trial of interpersonal psychotherapy v. cognitive behavior therapy. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 74, 1041–1054. http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/0022-006x.74.6.1041.Google Scholar
McHugh, RK, Whitton, SW, Peckham, AD, Welge, JA and Otto, MW (2013) Patient preference for psychological v. pharmacologic treatment of psychiatric disorders: a meta-analytic review. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 74, 595–602. http://dx.doi.org/10.4088/JCP.12r07757.Google Scholar
Mintz, D (2006) Combining drug therapy and psychotherapy for depression. Psychiatric Times 23, 18.Google Scholar
Miranda, J, Bernal, G, Lau, A, Kohn, L, Hwang, W-C and LaFromboise, T (2005) State of the science on psychosocial interventions for ethnic minorities. Annual Review of Clinical Psychology 1, 113–142. http://dx.doi.org/10.1146/annurev.clinpsy.1.102803.143822.Google Scholar
Moher, D, Liberati, A, Tetzlaff, J and Altman, DG and Group ATP (2009) Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA StatementThe PRISMA statement. Annals of Internal Medicine 151(4), 264–269. http://dx.doi.org/10.7326/0003-4819-151-4-200908180-00135.Google Scholar
NICE (2009) Depression: The treatment and management of depression in adults (CG90): National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence. http://www.nice.org.uk/CG90.Google Scholar
Orwin, RG (1983) A fail-safe N for effect size in meta-analysis. Journal of Educational Statistics 8, 157–159. http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/1164923.Google Scholar
Otto, MW, Smits, JAJ and Reese, HE (2005) Combined psychotherapy and pharmacotherapy for mood and anxiety disorders in adults: review and analysis. Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice 12, 72–86. http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/clipsy.bpi009.Google Scholar
Polanin, JR (2013) Addressing the issue of meta-analysis multiplicity in education and psychology. Dissertation. Paper 539. http://ecommons.luc.edu/luc_diss/539.Google Scholar
Rosenthal, R (1991) Meta-analysis: a review. Psychosomatic Medicine 53, 247–271. http://dx.doi.org/10.1097/00006842-199105000-00001.Google Scholar
Rossello, J, Bernal, G and Rivera-Medina, C (2008) Individual and group CBT and IPT for Puerto Rican adolescents with depressive symptoms. Cultural Diversity and Ethnic Minority Psychology 14, 234–245. http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/1099-9809.14.3.234.Google Scholar
Rucci, P, Frank, E, Calugi, S, Miniati, M, Benvenuti, A, Wallace, M, Fagiolini, A, Maggi, L, Kupfer, DJ and Cassano, GB (2011) Incidence and predictors of relapse during continuation treatment of major depression with SSRI, interpersonal psychotherapy, or their combination. Depression and Anxiety 28, 955–962. http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/da.20894.Google Scholar
Schindler, A, Hiller, W and Witthoft, M (2013) What predicts outcome, response, and drop-out in CBT of depressive adults? A naturalistic study. Behavior Cognitive Psychotherapy 41, 365–370. http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/s1352465812001063.Google Scholar
Shapiro, DA, Barkham, M, Rees, A, Hardy, GE, Reynolds, S and Startup, M (1994) Effects of treatment duration and severity of depression on the effectiveness of cognitive-behavioral and psychodynamic-interpersonal psychotherapy. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 62, 522–534.Google Scholar
Shinohara, K, Honyashiki, M, Imai, H, Hunot, V, Caldwell, DM, Davies, P, Moore, TH, Furukawa, TA and Churchill, R (2013) Behavioural therapies v. other psychological therapies for depression. Cochrane Database Systematic Reviews 2013/10/17, Cd008696. http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD008696.pub2.Google Scholar
Streiner, DL (2015) Best (but oft-forgotten) practices: the multiple problems of multiplicity—whether and how to correct for many statistical tests. The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 102, 721–728.Google Scholar
Thase, ME, Reynolds, CF, Frank, E, Simons, AD, McGeary, J, Fasiczka, AL, Garamoni, GG, Jennings, JR, Kupfer, DJ (1994) Do depressed men and women respond similarly to cognitive behavior therapy? American Journal of Psychiatry 151(4), 500–505.Google Scholar
Thase, ME, Greenhouse, JB, Frank, E, Reynolds, CF III, Pilkonis, PA, Hurley, K, Grochocinski, V and Kupfer, DJ (1997) Treatment of major depression with psychotherapy or psychotherapy-pharmacotherapy combinations. Archive of General Psychiatry 54, 1009–1015.Google Scholar
Weisz, JR, McCarty, CA and Valeri, SM (2006) Effects of psychotherapy for depression in children and adolescents: a meta-analysis. Psychology Bulletin 132, 132–149. http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.132.1.132.Google Scholar
Westen, D, Novotny, CM and Thompson-Brenner, H (2004) The empirical status of empirically supported psychotherapies: assumptions, findings, and reporting in controlled clinical trials. Psychology Bulletin 130, 631–663. http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.130.4.631.Google Scholar
WHO (1992) The ICD-10 Classification of Mental and Behavioral Disorders: clinical descriptions and diagnostic guidelines. Geneva, Switzerland.Google Scholar
WHO (2017) Depression fact sheet. Available at http://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/depression [accessed].Google Scholar
Yusuf, S, Wittes, J, Probstfield, J and Tyroler, HA (1991) Analysis and interpretation of treatment effects in subgroups of patients in randomized clinical trials. JAMA 266, 93–98.Google Scholar
Zhou, S-G, Hou, Y-F, Liu, D and Zhang, X-Y (2017) Effect of cognitive behavioral therapy v. interpersonal psychotherapy in patients with major depressive disorder: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Chinese Medical Journal 130, 2844–2851. http://dx.doi.org/10.4103/0366-6999.219149.Google Scholar
Supplementary material: File

Whiston et al. supplementary material

Whiston et al. supplementary material

Download Whiston et al. supplementary material(File)
File 151.1 KB