Hostname: page-component-55f67697df-q9hcs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-05-10T00:51:16.609Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Dialogics of Legal Meaning: Spectacular Trials, the Unwritten Law, and Narratives of Criminal Responsibility

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 April 2024

Martha Merrill Umphrey
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Drawing upon Mikhail Bakhtin's theory of the dialogic, this essay explores the production of legal meanings about criminal responsibility in the 19th and early 20th centuries. In particular, it examines the honor-based defense of the “unwritten law” as it was articulated in relation to the formal law of provocation in the 19th century, and in the 1906 trial of Harry K. Thaw for the murder of Stanford White. Meanings about criminal responsibility emerge, I argue, from a process of discursive conflict and negotiation between the domains of legal consciousness and formal law. At trial, competing narratives of indictment and exoneration literally enact that dynamic process, so that trials may be said to be the materialization of the dialogic production of “law” in its broadest sense.

Type
Professional and Popular Conceptions of Criminal Responsibility
Information
Law & Society Review , Volume 33 , Issue 2 , 1999 , pp. 393 - 423
Copyright
Copyright © 1999 by The Law and Society Association.

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Article purchase

Temporarily unavailable

Footnotes

I owe great thanks to Karen Merrill, Lawrence Douglas, Jay Grossman, Nasser Hus-sain, Austin Sarat, Susan Silbey, Alison Young, and several anonymous reviewers for their insightful and helpful comments.

References

References

Abramson, Phyllis (1990) Sob Sister Journalism. New York: Greenwood Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Atwell, Benjamin (1907a) The Great Harry Thaw Case; Or, A Woman's Sacrifice. Chicago: Laird & Lee.Google Scholar
Atwell, Benjamin (1907b) The Unwritten Law: A Thrilling Drama Based on the Thaw-White Case. New York: Sigmund Lubin.Google Scholar
Bakhtin, Mikhail (1981) The Dialogic Imagination, ed. Holquist, M.. Trans. Emerson, C. & Holquist, M.. Austin: Univ. of Texas.Google Scholar
Holquist, M. (1984a) Rabelais and His World. trans. Iswolsky, H.. Bloomington: Indiana Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Iswolsky, H. (1984b) Problems of Dostoevsky's Poetics, ed. & trans. Emerson, C.. Minneapolis: Univ. of Minnesota.Google Scholar
Emerson, C. (1986a) Speech Genres and Other Late Essays, ed. Emerson, C. & Holquist, M.. Trans. McGee, V.. Austin: Univ. of Texas Press.Google Scholar
Bakhtin, Mikhail [as Volosinov, V. N.] (1986b) Marxism and the Philosophy of Language. trans. Matejka, L. & Titunik, I. R.. Cambridge: Harvard Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Bakhtin, Mikhail, & Medvedev, P. N. (1978) The Formal Method in Literary Scholarship: A Critical Introduction to Sociological Poetics. trans. Wehrle, A. J.. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Barthes, Roland (1974) S/Z. trans. Miller, R.. New York: Hill & Wang.Google Scholar
Bell, Clark (1907) “The Defense of Insanity in Criminal Cases and Medical Expert Testimony: Practical Steps toward Reform,” 15 American Lawyer 314.Google Scholar
Bennet, W. Lance, & Feldman, Martha (1981) Reconstructing Reality in the Courtroom: Justice and Judgment in American Culture. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Berenson, Edward (1992) The Trial of Madame Caillaux. Berkeley: Univ. of California Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brooks, Peter (1976) The Melodramatic Imagination: Balzac, Henry James, Melodrama, and the Mode of Excess. New Haven, CT: Yale Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Brooks, Peter (1984) Reading for the Plot: Design and Intention in Narrative. New York: Alfred A. Knopf.Google Scholar
Brooks, Peter, & Gewirtz, Paul, eds. (1996) Law's Stories: Narrative and Rhetoric in the Law. New Haven, CT: Yale Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Brown, Richard Maxwell (1975) Strain of Violence: Historical Studies of American Violence and Vigilantism. New York: Oxford Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Brown, Richard Maxwell (1991) No Duty to Retreat. New York: Oxford Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Chambers, Ross (1984) Story and Situation: Narrative Seduction and the Power of Fiction. Minneapolis: Univ. of Minnesota Press.Google Scholar
Dickson, Bruce (1979) Violence and Culture in the Antebellum South. Austin: Univ. of Texas Press.Google Scholar
Engel, David M. (1993) “Law in the Domains of Everyday Life: The Construction of Community and Difference,” in Sarat, A. & Kearns, T. R., eds., Law in Everyday Life. Ann Arbor: Univ. of Michigan.Google Scholar
Engel, David M., & Munger, Frank W. (1996) “Rights, Remembrance, and the Reconciliation of Difference,” 30 Law & Society Rev. 7–53.Google Scholar
Ewick, Patricia, & Silbey, Susan S. (1995) “Subversive Stories and Hegemonic Tales: Toward a Sociology of Narrative.” 29 Law & Society Rev. 197–226.Google Scholar
Silbey, Susan S. (1998) The Common Place of Law: Stories from Everyday Life. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Ferguson, Robert (1994) “Story and Transcription in the Trial of John Brown,” 6 Yale J. of Law & the Humanities 37–73.Google Scholar
Ferguson, Robert (1996) “Untold Stories in the Law,” in Brooks & Gewirtz, eds. 1996.Google Scholar
Friedman, Lawrence M. (1993) Crime and Punishment in American History. New York: Basic Books.Google Scholar
Ganz, Melissa (1997) “Wicked Women and Veiled Ladies: Gendered Narratives of the McFarland-Richardson Trial,” 9 Yale J. of Law & Feminism 255–303.Google Scholar
Gewirtz, Paul (1996) “Narrative and Rhetoric in the Law,” in Brooks & Gewirtz, eds. 1996.Google Scholar
Gordon, Robert W. (1984) “Critical Legal Histories,” 36 Stanford Law Review 57–125.Google Scholar
Halsey, L. M. (1908) “Expert Medical Testimony,” 8 American Medical Association Bull. 167–68.Google Scholar
Hamilton, Allan McLane (1907) “The Defense of Insanity in Criminal Cases and Medical Expert Testimony: An Expert's View,” 15 American Lawyer 311.Google Scholar
Harris, Ruth (1991) Murders and Madness. London: Clarendon Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hartog, Hendrik (1997) “Lawyering, Husband's Rights, and ‘the Unwritten Law’ in Nineteenth-Century America,” 84(1) J. of American History 67–96.Google Scholar
Herrnstein Smith, Barbara (1981) “Narrative Versions, Narrative Theories” in Mitchell, W. J. T., ed., On Narrative. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Ireland, Robert W. (1989) “The Libertine Must Die: Sexual Dishonor and the Unwritten Law in the Nineteenth-Century United States,” 23 (1) J. of Social History 27–44.Google Scholar
Jackson, Bernard (1988) Law, Fact, and Narrative Coherence. London: Deborah Charles Publications.Google Scholar
Keedy, Edwin R. (1911–12) “Report of the Committee on Insanity and Criminal Responsibility,” 2 J. of the American Institute of Criminal Law & Criminology 521–38.Google Scholar
Keedy, Edwin R. (1915) “A Bill to Regulate Expert Testimony,” 5 J. of the American Institute of Criminal Law & Criminology 643–52.Google Scholar
Kernan, Thomas J. (1906) “The Jurisprudence of Lawlessness” 29 Reports of the American Bar Association 450–67.Google Scholar
Korobkin, Laura Hanft (1995) “The Maintenance of Mutual Confidence: Sentimental Strategies at the Adultery Trial of Henry Ward Beecher,” 7 Yale J. of Law and the Humanities 1–48.Google Scholar
Langford, Gerald (1962) The Murder of Stanford White. Indianapolis: Bobbs-Mer-rill.Google Scholar
Mackenzie, F. A. (1928) The Trial of Harry Thaw. London: Geoffrey Bles.Google Scholar
Mason, Jeffrey D. (1993) Melodrama and the Myth of America. Bloomington: Indiana Univ. Press.Google Scholar
McIntyre, John F. (1909) “The Defense of Insanity in Criminal Cases and Medical Expert Testimony: A Condemnation of the Present System,” 15 American Lawyer 312–14.Google Scholar
Miller, William Ian (1993) Humiliation and Other Essays on Honor, Social Discomfort, and Violence. Ithaca, NY: Cornell Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Moran, Richard (1981) Knowing Right from Wrong: The Insanity Defense of Daniel McNaughtan. New York: Free Press.Google Scholar
Nesbit, Evelyn (1934) Prodigal Days: The Untold Story. New York: Julian Messner, Inc.Google Scholar
Osborne, James W. (1907) “The Defense of Insanity in Criminal Cases and Medical Expert Testimony: A Defense of the Present System,” 15 American Lawyer 311–12.Google Scholar
Pound, Roscoe (1907) “The Need of a Sociological Jurisprudence,” 19 Green Bag 607–15.Google Scholar
Robertson, Cara (1996) “Representing ‘Miss Lizzie’: Cultural Convictions in the Trial of Lizzie Borden,” 8 Yale J. of Law & the Humanities 351–416.Google Scholar
Sarat, Austin, & Felstiner, William L. F. (1995) Divorce Lawyers and Their Clients: Power and Meaning in the Legal Process. New York: Oxford Univ. Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Silbey, Susan (1992) “Making a Place for Cultural Analyses of Law,” 17 Law & Social Inquiry 39–48.Google Scholar
Somerville, Henderson M. (1907) “The Defense of Insanity in Criminal Cases and Medical Expert Testimony: A Judicial View,” 15 American Lawyer 309–10.Google Scholar
Tighe, Janet A. (1983) “Francis Wharton and the Nineteenth-Century Insanity Defense: The Origins of a Reform Tradition,” 27 American J. of Legal History 223–53.Google Scholar
Weisberg, Robert (1992) “Private Violence as Moral Action: The Law as Inspiration and Example,” in Sarat, A. & Kearns, T., eds., Law's Violence. Ann Arbor: Univ. of Michigan Press.Google Scholar
Wharton, Francis (1855) A Treatise on the Law of Homicide in the United States. Philadelphia: Kay & Brother.Google Scholar
Wharton, Francis (1875) A Treatise on the Law of Homicide in the United States. 2d ed. Philadelphia: Kay & Brother.Google Scholar
Wharton, Francis (1907) The Law of Homicide. 3d ed., ed. F. H. Bowlby. Rochester, NY: Lawyers Co-operative Publishing Co.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wharton, Helen E., ed. (1891) Francis Wharton: A Memoir. Philadelphia.Google Scholar
Wrong, Dennis H. (1979) Power: Its Forms, Bases and Uses. New York: Harper & Row.Google Scholar
Wyatt-Brown, Bertram (1982) Southern Honor: Ethics and Behavior in the Old South. New York: Oxford Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Yale Law Journal (1934) Comment: “Recognition of the Honor Defense under the Insanity Plea,” 43 Yale Law J. 809–14.Google Scholar

Cases

Biggs v. State, 29 Ga. 723 (1860).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
[Cole-Hiscock (1868)] (1882) “George W. Cole,” in Remarkable Trials of All Countries, vol. 2, ed. Dunphy, T.. New York: S. S. Peloubet & Co.Google Scholar
[McFarland-Richardson (1870)] “The Trial of Daniel McFarland for the Shooting of Albert D. Richardson, the Alleged Seducer of His Wife.” Compiled by Cazauran, A. R.. New York: W. E. Hilton.Google Scholar
[Sickles-Key (1859)] “The Washington Tragedy,” in Murder Trials: Cole 1867; McFarland 1870; Sickles 1859 [compilation], Bangor: Maine State Library.Google Scholar

Statutes

Texas Penal Code Annotated, sec. 1220 (1861).Google Scholar
New Mexico Comp. Laws, sec. 1076 (1897).Google Scholar
Utah Comp. Laws, sec. 1925 (1876).Google Scholar